The Thinking Practitioner Podcast
w/ Til Luchau & Whitney Lowe
Thinking Practitioner Podcast, Ep 182: Shoulder Pain: Stop Blaming the Sore Spot (with Whitney Lowe & Til Luchau)
Transcript | Subscribe | Comments | ⭑⭑⭑⭑⭑
Or, listen and subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, wherever you get your podcasts!
🎁 Scroll down for the full video and transcript!
🎙 182: Shoulder Pain: Stop Blaming the Sore Spot (with Whitney Lowe & Til Luchau)
What if the sore spot isn’t the whole shoulder story—and the work that feels good today makes it worse tomorrow?
A tendon to treat, a joint to mobilize, a movement pattern to correct: familiar starting points for shoulder work. But what if they don’t help—or keep things stirred up? Til brings his own stubborn shoulder into a conversation about what tenderness, movement, and history can tell us.
Whitney and Til explore how mechanics, nerve symptoms, and broader sensitivity can shape our choices. They compare targeted work with gentler exploration, discuss referred pain and medical referral, and consider how to help clients find comfortable movement while rebuilding capacity. The useful question isn’t just “Did that help?” but “How was it the next day?”
✨ We talk about:
• Daily demands and short-lived relief
• Tenderness: when direct work helps or aggravates
• Active, passive, and resisted movement clues
• Scapular mechanics, tendon irritability, and sensitivity
• Nerve symptoms, referred pain, and medical referral
• Loading tissues and finding movement you enjoy
• Next-day feedback, self-care, and changing course
✨ And tell us what happened: What changed a stubborn shoulder case for you? Email us — we’d love to hear it.
✨ Resources:
• Til Luchau, Advanced Myofascial Techniques, Vol. 1: https://advanced-trainings.com/product/advanced-myofascial-techniques-vol1/
• Greg Lehman’s pain and recovery resources: https://www.greglehman.ca/recovery-strategies-pain-guidebook
• Related episode: Nerve Pain: Stop Blaming Compression (179): https://www.thethinkingpractitioner.com/e/179-nerve-pain-stop-blaming-compression-with-whitney-lowe-til-luchau/
🌱 Sponsor Offers:
• Jane – Try it free for one month with code THINKING1MO at https://a-t.tv/jane
• ABMP – Save on new membership at https://abmp.com/thinking
• Books of Discovery – Save 15% with code THINKING at https://booksofdiscovery.com
• Advanced-Trainings – Try one month free of the A-T Subscription with code THINKING at https://a-t.tv/subscriptions
• Academy of Clinical Massage – Grab Whitney’s free Assessment Cheat Sheet at https://academyofclinicalmassage.com/cheatsheet
✨ Watch the video / connect with us:
• YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AdvancedTrainings/podcasts
• Whitney Lowe – https://academyofclinicalmassage.com | https://facebook.com/WhitneyLowe | https://twitter.com/whitneylowe
• Til Luchau – https://advanced-trainings.com | https://facebook.com/advancedtrainings | https://instagram.com/til.luchau
📧 Email us: info@thethinkingpractitioner.com
The Thinking Practitioner Podcast is intended for professional practitioners of manual and movement therapies — bodywork, massage therapy, structural integration, physical therapy, osteopathy, and similar professions. It is not medical or treatment advice.
Full Transcript (click me!)
The Thinking Practitioner Podcast:
Episode 182: Stop Blaming the Sore Spot (with Whitney Lowe & Til Luchau)
Til Luchau 00:00
They’re irritated already, and us putting pressure on them, or trying to glide them, or challenging them in a mechanical way, can actually feel really good in a moment because that’s what hurts. But like a lot of those things, end up hurting more later. Some of what we’re doing to try to help, it could be keeping it in an aggravated state, and it’s hard to see that when it’s happening. Yeah,
Til Luchau 00:26
it’s hard to tell. Welcome to the Thinking Practitioner Podcast, a podcast where we dig into the fascinating issues, conditions, and quandaries in the massage and manual therapy world today.
Whitney Lowe 00:36
I’m Whitney Lowe,
Til Luchau 00:37
and I’m Til Luchau.
Whitney Lowe 00:39
Welcome to the Thinking Practitioner,
Til Luchau 00:43
you’ve heard us talk about Jane before, and we keep mentioning them for a reason. We’re selective about who we partner with. We want sponsors whose values align with ours and who genuinely serve this community. Jane fits that bill. They’re a practice management platform built specifically for health and wellness practitioners. Simple enough for solo practitioners, but powerful enough for clinics and groups.
Whitney Lowe 01:05
And what really caught our attention is Jane’s reputation for customer service: real humans available by phone, email, or chat, even on Saturdays. That kind of support is increasingly rare, and it says a lot about a company. So, if you’re looking to simplify the business side of your practice, check them out at a-t.tv/jane. Once again, that is a-t.tv/jane, and Thinking Practitioner listeners can get a free first month by entering the code Thinking1mo. That is Thinking 1mo at checkout.
Til Luchau 01:42
And today. in-house sponsor is Advanced-Trainings Are you ready to take your skills to the next level? Come visit us at AdvancedTrainings.com. With innovative self-paced programs ranging from one-hour certificate courses on the most common client complaints to our comprehensive CAMT certification program, we offer practice-changing learning events with industry-leading instructors and support a supportive learning community that will take your work to another level.
Whitney Lowe 02:10
And also for a limited time, Thinking Practitioner listeners can enjoy a special offer. So sign up today at Advanced-trainings.com and get a free month of the amazing AT subscription. So again, explore the extensive library of courses, cancel at any time, and keep your credits all from just $20 a month with the first month free for the TTP listeners.
Til Luchau 02:32
Thanks, Whitney. Plus, it’s not too late to join us for one of our amazing retreats, like our walking workshop on the Camino de Santiago in Portugal and Spain, or our bodywork and movement retreats in Thailand, or our popular Pelvis, Hip, and Sacrum course live online in the new year. So why wait? Why wait? Visit advanced-trainings.com today.
Whitney Lowe 02:54
You’ll be glad you did.
Til Luchau 02:55
Yeah, be glad you did, Whitney. How are you doing there?
Whitney Lowe 02:58
I’m doing well, sir. How are you doing today?
Til Luchau 03:01
I’m okay. I got a little hitch in my shoulder giddy up when I raise my arm a little bit. No way. Yeah, I do. What do you What do you want to talk about today?
Whitney Lowe 03:12
Well, let’s talk about shoulders then. Why don’t we do that?
Til Luchau 03:14
Let’s do that. I was excited to have this topic roll up on our menu of options here because yeah, I I’ve been personally dealing with a shoulder sensitivity.
Whitney Lowe 03:26
Oh, okay. So this is for real, yeah.
Til Luchau 03:28
For about six seven months now, so I got I’ve got some ideas and I’ve got some puzzles, and I look forward to thinking them through with you.
Whitney Lowe 03:39
Cool. Let’s do.
Til Luchau 03:41
Let’s start out with the question. Like again, I’ve been dealing with mine for six or seven months. Why is shoulder pain so stubborn? Do you think why why are certain shoulder problems especially challenging? You got any ideas about that?
Whitney Lowe 03:56
I have biased ideas. I think yeah, I definitely have ideas about it. I think, in many instances, a lot of these kinds of problems, you know, come back to the point that this is biomechanically one of the most complex regions of the human body because it demands an extreme, extensive range of motion. At the same time, so many soft tissues are given the responsibility of maintaining stability at that location, because despite the fact that the glenohumeral joint is called a ball and socket joint, the reality is there’s not much socket there. It’s really kind of a a ball and slightly curved dish kind of arrangement there, and architecturally, you know, there’s some other major big challenges with you know a very small subacromial space where you can potentially pinch structures and squeeze things and fray them and do all kinds of stuff and and just let’s face it we use the shoulders and the arms all the time for all these different things that we’re doing climbing throwing reaching pulling lift. And all this kind of stuff. Lots of demands on that leaning on
Til Luchau 05:03
the shoulder rest plane. I just did a plane ride. That was that was the challenge there. How do I get comfortable in the seat
Whitney Lowe 05:10
when
Til Luchau 05:11
shoulder rest was in a position that was demanding for me?
Whitney Lowe 05:14
Yeah, yeah.
Til Luchau 05:15
So the structural the structural differences to the shoulder joint that make them makes it vulnerable to perhaps being sensitized or injured or having a harder time recovering if those things do happen, and then there’s neurological or sensitivity issues. There, we have tons of mechanoreceptors all around that joint at every level, from joint capsule out to the ligaments, out to the muscles and tendons and fascia and scan that surround that joint, also that we can monitor what’s happening in this super mobile and super useful, super employed joint, so that when something is uncomfortable, there’s a lot of signal there. There’s a lot of things that are unhappy and telling us you
Whitney Lowe 06:01
hear about it. That’s right. Yeah, you hear about it. It’s like the kid in class who’s the the loudest one saying things all the time. You hear about it quite a lot.
Til Luchau 06:10
It’s also super common. I don’t have the statistics right here in front of me, but I know that in my series of courses that cover the whole body, shoulder issues was always one of the most popular ones, and that if I wanted to do an online course for the ABMP or something like that, if the word shoulder was in the title, lots of people would come. I think it was YouTube also. These are my scientific statistics about shoulder prevalence. That means I think that means to me maybe shoulders hurt a lot, but also it means practitioners are looking for ideas. We want to know how to help these clients coming in with shoulder issues.
Whitney Lowe 06:47
Yeah, and I think those two things are clearly intricately woven together because people want to know a lot about shoulder things because they hear about it a lot. And and the other thing, and we’ll get into this a little bit deeper, is it’s not always easy to find the best solution for these things, too. They end up oftentimes being long-term, stubborn kinds of complaints that that last for for quite a while.
Til Luchau 07:10
Pretty common for a shoulder to feel better after a session and then feel bad again.
Whitney Lowe 07:15
Yeah.
Til Luchau 07:16
What are some of the factors you think of when we speculate about why that could be. I think a
Whitney Lowe 07:22
lot of it is, you know, a lot of it has to do with you know part of what you mentioned, especially with neurological system and the extreme innervation to these areas. There’s lots of things that can get irritated, and you can do some things to improve some of that on the short term, but we go out and then immediately do things. Many times I think kind of like it’s hard to just not do stuff and rest the shoulder appropriately to really let it heal the way it needs to sometimes.
Til Luchau 07:48
That’s huge. Had a guy coming in tennis, very serious amateur tennis player, pretty high in the rankings in his league, and had some shoulder pain, and he tried lots of things, and I was one of his final stops. I think you know, he. But at some point, I did some stuff that really helped. But at some point, I said, “Listen, you know, it’s the if no one said this, someone needs to, and that is that changing what you do might be your main lever to making a difference here.
Whitney Lowe 08:21
Right.
Til Luchau 08:21
And he says, “Like, oh boy, yeah, I don’t want to hear that, but yeah, that’s you know, that’s the deal. Like, we we do we want to keep doing the things we love, and we need to do certain things. We need to open the door. We need to you know drive the car. We need to do all kinds of things that involve the shoulder, and it’s hard to shift those patterns both for the demands upon us and are things that give us satisfaction.
Whitney Lowe 08:44
Yeah, and I think it’s important for us to remember too that I mean the example that you gave here is somebody who’s got a real serious interest in doing something that is meaningful for them. But sometimes it’s I have to work. You know, I’m a hairdresser. I have to hold my arms up in an abduct position all day long. I don’t have a choice. This is what I have to do, and so there’s that on top of like not just knowing that it would be better if you didn’t do as much of it, but you can’t stop, you know, for various reasons.
Til Luchau 09:13
That is a challenge. That’s a challenge there.
Whitney Lowe 09:15
Yeah,
Til Luchau 09:16
and we and we you know just you know bookmarking the idea that we can still play a role, even if what someone wants is fix my shoulder, so I can go back to doing everything I’ve been doing the way I did it before. Sometimes that works, sometimes it doesn’t. But even when it doesn’t work, there’s ways we can be helpful too.
Whitney Lowe 09:34
Yeah. Well, let’s kind of let’s kind of start with I think where a lot of us start, which is somebody comes in and says, “My shoulder hurts, you know, and and oftentimes they may point to something and you know say like, “Here’s where it hurts right here, or you know, “I did it after I fell off the ladder, or whatever it is. So these are some of the things I think. Certainly, as as manual therapists, our focus is great deal on you know. Where does it hurt? Can you press on something that reproduces it, and what does that tell us? And this is, you know, certainly palpation becomes a really critical part of what we’re doing. But at the same time, there’s a number of instances in which you know internal structures inside the shoulder are not easily accessible to palpation, and it still may hurt, and they just can’t really put their finger on it, but they can tell you it hurts. Absolutely. So yeah, I think a lot of a lot of where we end up starting is trying to figure out like what is it that’s hurting and why does this hurt. So and what’s saying that yeah with with local tenderness, how does that kind of how does that guide you?
Til Luchau 10:37
You’re saying a client comes in and we’re assessing to see what we think is happening and how we might help, and local tenderness-meaning I can press on it and make it hurt. How does that factor into my thinking? Do I get the question?
Whitney Lowe 10:50
Yeah.
Til Luchau 10:52
Yes, it’s a good question, and my ideas about it have changed over time.
Whitney Lowe 10:57
Well, let’s hear about that. And what change?
Til Luchau 10:59
There’s lots of things that could be making someone’s shoulder hurt, so I wouldn’t say it’s always this way or always that way. But there are times that locally tender places need some attention, and then they are less attention, less sorry, less tender, and the shoulder’s happier. There’s times when we work the spots that hurt in a in a deliberate or skilled way that allows them to become less sensitized, and there’s lots of ways people do that, and that’s all it takes. There are other times when the locally tender spots get worse with direct attention, particularly I can think of you know tendinopathy, long head of the biceps, typically supraspinatus tendons. Some of these tendons that cross the joint there, they’re irritated already, and us putting pressure on them or trying to glide them or challenging them in a mechanical way can actually feel really good in a moment because that’s what hurts, but like a lot of those things end up hurting more later.
Whitney Lowe 12:06
Yeah,
Til Luchau 12:08
and then there’s I’m just making this up. Did you want to say something about that?
Whitney Lowe 12:11
No, I was just going to say that this is one of the things that I think we have to grapple with a lot in the treatment realm is when it you know a client calls you up a day or two later, says, “Yeah, I was felt good when I left, but man, the next day I was really sore. I think this is an important distinction of trying to distinguish post-treatment soreness that might be like you know a workout kind of soreness from a flare-up or aggravation of a pre-existing complaint. Yeah, because those two things have different causes, and and and they mean different things.
Til Luchau 12:46
They do, and it’s you’re making me think of of some of my own process with my own stubborn but improving shoulder, working with a strength and conditioning coach, a personal trainer who’s really quite skilled, and one of the things he really does is carefully monitor how my shoulder is doing through these different exercises we’re doing. But he consistently texts me the next day, “How was that? How’s it doing today? And then he adjusts what he’s doing based on that because we are looking for, we share the model that some load is beneficial, but too much load is going to be aggravating and just keep things flared up. And again, not this doesn’t apply to all shoulder problems. This is my particular complex manifestation. But you’ll you’ll again meet a lot of clients who could get flared up. Mine actually was injured getting some body work. It was a body worker who felt something really delicious to work on right here at the big front of my shoulder, and she really went for it. And I, you know, let her do a little bit, and then I slowed her down. So that might be a bit much, but it it it hurt more and continued to hurt more, and that gets me into that third category of things I was going to talk about, which is there’s local tenderness, there’s maybe inflamed or aggravated local tendinopathies, and then there’s a general sensitivity that seemed to come in in my case, and I’ve seen clients too, where everything gets a little protective and sore, and things. My neck got tight, my ribcage was feeling bad, my other shoulder started getting cranky, and so there’s somehow it goes systemic in a way. I don’t think it was literally like a systemic inflammation or infection, but the sensitivity, maybe it’s that region of my brain getting aggravated. Who knows the mechanism? But it was beyond that single point of injury in my case.
Whitney Lowe 14:50
Yeah, I mean that’s a really just classic, great example of that progression through the different pain phenotypes. The you know the. International Association for the Study of Pain has these three pain phenotypes: the nociceptive pain, which sounds like where it started with a primary tissue irritation, and has progressed. It sounds like now into more of a nociceptive pain situation, where there is more global responses throughout the other parts of the shoulder region, and now extending over into you said neck and other opposite shoulder as well, and so now this has become not just a local tissue problem, but more of a central nervous system processing problem as well.
Til Luchau 15:35
The third type being neuropathic pain, which I unfortunately not to have experienced with this one, but I have right now a shoulder client who that’s his main complaint. He’s got tendering and numbness down to his arm. That’s been difficult and stubborn for him to address.
Whitney Lowe 15:50
Yeah, yeah. So, what’s
Til Luchau 15:53
anything you want to add about your thoughts on local tenderness?
Whitney Lowe 15:57
Yeah, I did want to something that came to mind that I just did did want to add, you know, when you were talking about your own situation and how that how that came about, and this is a classic example, I think, too, of my personal feeling about the critical importance of of assessment, because history taking is just a critical part of making some of those determinations about why there might be local tissue tenderness in a in a certain area. Is it because there were adverse forces in the area, or was it something that was metabolically driven, or you know was it just come up out of the? I mean, there there are painful shoulder conditions that appear to just come out of the blue with no reason whatsoever, like calcific tendinitis is an example.
Til Luchau 16:40
Adhesive adhesive capsulitis, yeah, things like that. Yeah, that seem to arise.
Whitney Lowe 16:44
And so that taking a really comprehensive history is super valuable for sort of highlighting what are some of those factors that might make us think about a local tissue as the cause versus you know some other type of of causative factors that might be leading to that that pain problem.
Til Luchau 17:05
History did it arise suddenly? Was there a specific injury? I’ll change how you’re thinking. What would your approach? How would your approach differ in each of those cases, or would it?
Whitney Lowe 17:15
Oh yeah, absolutely, it would. I mean, because for example, if something looked to be, you know, a sudden acute level injury from, let’s say, falling on your shoulder. You know, having a body worker on one part of a too much. Yeah, too much. Yeah, that’s clearly something where, and if you tackle that early and get it early, oftentimes you have a lot better chance of resolving something in those earlier stages, when it’s just a nociceptive problem, before it has now expanded into a nociceptive type of thing or neuropathic and in other situations like that. So, for me, that absolutely does guide a lot of the treatment strategies for how I would tend to approach that, and it will also, for me, guide what I’m going to do in the other parts of the assessment to verify my hypothesis of what’s happening. You know, stress those particular tissues through physical examination methods with active movement and passive movement and resisted movements, and see if we can build a comprehensive pattern of tissue responses that makes sense. That like, oh yeah, that really makes sense. If this is what’s going on, that’s likely to do that. Or like this does not make sense. If this was the problem, that shouldn’t be doing this or should be doing this. So those are the things that I think are really critical there. So and so that kind of gets us into like you know looking at what are how do we pull those things into sort of guiding where we’re going. So, how how do you sort of feel like we’ve talked about some of the assessment strategies there, and then you know treatment methods and things like that. But movement is so critical here in the shoulder region. So, how do you think how how important is that corrective movement for doing that. Maybe talk a little bit about your own process with your shoulder and what you think about with others.
Til Luchau 19:07
Okay, my again til’s opinions here, and
Whitney Lowe 19:09
yeah,
Til Luchau 19:10
movement’s a big category, and there you said corrective movement. I don’t tend to work from the idea that there is an optimal way to move the shoulder, I don’t tend to think that way. Some of that’s my post rolfing trauma from working in a system that had very clear ideals. Some of that’s just my authority issues, myself, but there’s some of it’s just looking to see what if I don’t try to impose a template or a pattern of movement, but look to see what’s possible and increase the options there. Yeah. So I’m not the idea of scapular dyskinesis and et cetera. I, it’s just not. Map I follow,
Whitney Lowe 20:01
yeah. Can you just briefly kind of semi define that term scapular dyskinesis because it does get tossed around a good bit. Define the
Til Luchau 20:09
map I don’t follow. Okay,
Whitney Lowe 20:11
sure.
Til Luchau 20:11
Maybe maybe I can jump in on it too.
Whitney Lowe 20:13
Yeah,
Til Luchau 20:13
yeah. Please, as I understand it, it’s the idea that there are dysfunctional patterns that the of sequencing through the humerus and scapula and movement. There’s some things we are desirable. There’s other patterns that are less desirable, and that people are likely to have more problems if they are dysfunctional in their sequencing and combinations of movements. Yeah,
Whitney Lowe 20:37
I thought that was excellent. And you one a couple things I would add on there is that I think part of the debate that I hear a lot about the term and the concepts around scapular dyskinesis is kind of goes back to that whole idea of we need to get everybody to move a certain way of trying to get you know like the shoulder needs to move this particular way and seeing it as a set of rules and and sort of guidelines and things like that, or to think
Til Luchau 21:06
that if we teach someone to do that, their shoulder pain will change. Right, that that’s going
Whitney Lowe 21:10
to make that better. If you just get your movement fixed, then this will be all better. Or if you
Til Luchau 21:14
get your alignment fixed, things should have been same. Yeah,
Whitney Lowe 21:18
yeah, and I don’t personally subscribe to the sort of models like you were saying of like this is kind of like an absolute that we need to get this kind of thing done a specific way, but I do think there’s there’s some really important and valuable concepts within the models of scapular dyskinesis that are valuable to look at. So just as an example, when a person abducts their arm out to the side, there is a a really important coordinated movement between scapular upward rotation and glenohumeral abduction. And if that’s not happening, and you see a person trying to abduct their shoulder and their scapula is not moving, it’s a really good reason that they likely have shoulder pain from subacromial compression because let me you’re not.
Til Luchau 22:06
Let me see if I follow. You’re saying if I bring my arm straight out to the side,
Whitney Lowe 22:10
yeah,
Til Luchau 22:10
glenohumeral abduction. You want some scapular elevation too, upward
Whitney Lowe 22:19
rotation mostly. Upward rotation, upward rotation of the and that scapula needs to tilt upwards because if it doesn’t, then the acromion process is gonna your your humeral head is gonna pinge impinge structures underneath the acromion process and so there’s
Til Luchau 22:33
another little geeky movement in there that’s really been a key for for me it was it was like the holy grail for much of my clients, and that was inferior glide of the glenohumeral head on the scapula. Yeah, put a whole chapter in my book about it because getting that humerus to glide against the scapula rather than roll managed to avoid that impingement. Yeah, too.
Whitney Lowe 22:58
Yeah, and this is a good example too of of where massage therapists can play a significant role in that, because you know there are some particular tissues that are key to that inferior glide of the humeral head, and if they are super hypertonic and tight and don’t allow that appropriate movement, then you’re likely to see dysfunctional mechanics, and they’re leading to certain types of problems.
Til Luchau 23:25
Okay, I
Whitney Lowe 23:26
agree. Yeah, because I because
Til Luchau 23:27
I again because I’ve had such good results with that single idea. In fact, it was really it took me a while to realize the exceptions. It took me a while to realize, like, wait a minute, they’re not getting better. Why is that? I got their humorous to glide inferiorly. Why does their shoulder still hurt? Yeah, that’s where my learning really started to expand because there were so many people I was able to help with that single-minded focus on mobility
Whitney Lowe 23:54
in a
Til Luchau 23:55
particular way.
Whitney Lowe 23:56
And just one real quick again, one other thing we didn’t mention a whole lot, but I still think is important too, and this has to do with looking at you know the whole dyskinesis model is weakness or you know inappropriate activation of certain shoulder muscles. So, for example, you know if there is compression of the long thoracic nerve in the neck, that’s a motor nerve to the serratus anterior muscle, which is a key muscle for that upward rotation of the scapula, and if that nerve, for example, is getting compressed in the neck, this is not necessarily a shoulder problem until the serratus anterior doesn’t do its job in lifting the scapula up, and you see a person with you know extensive scapular winging, you know where the scapula pulls off the thoracic ribcage,
Til Luchau 24:41
yeah,
Whitney Lowe 24:41
that’s indicative of serratus anterior weakness, and that’s a likely cause of shoulder mechanics problems in there as well. Okay,
Whitney Lowe 24:50
yeah,
Til Luchau 24:50
okay. There’s also things that if it hurts when I actively abduct, but but I lift my client’s arm and it doesn’t hurt. That tells me a lot too,
Whitney Lowe 24:59
right?
Til Luchau 25:00
Active. If I can, if someone can provoke the pain through an active movement, that makes me think. Obviously, muscular, probably tenderness, or the things related to the muscular transmission of force being the sensitized structures.
Whitney Lowe 25:15
Exactly.
Til Luchau 25:16
Yeah. As opposed to passively induced sensitivity, could still be those same things, but that brings in the joint structures and the joint capsule and things that could be getting impinged, pinched, or maybe stretched. But for sure, somehow sensitized in the passive motion. That tells me again some tissue differences or target differences,
Whitney Lowe 25:42
yeah, and that’s that whole aspect of pattern recognition, kind of what I was highlighting before. I think is so critical in trying to make some of those determinations. And I, I do frequently like to mention to people to, to note that the shoulder is one of the few places in the body where you see some exceptions to those general rules, which you just mentioned, the fact that muscle tissues can get compressed during passive movements, especially the supraspinatus subscapularis, muscle tendon units can become painful during a passive movement because they’re getting pinched and compressed under that coracoacromial arch, and so this is sort of an important exception to the rule, but that again is part of the whole pattern recognition process. I think,
Til Luchau 26:28
and to understand that there’s so many patterns because again we get the ones that work and we tend to see all the problems through that lens. Like you’re thinking, I got this mobility thing going that’s going to help everybody. Sometimes it’s something different. Sometimes, in my case, again, it’s sensitivity that seems to be working its way through.
Whitney Lowe 26:47
Right?
Til Luchau 26:48
Do you want to? Are we ready to talk about referred pain? And
Whitney Lowe 26:51
yeah, that’s
Til Luchau 26:52
a
Whitney Lowe 26:52
fascinating piece of the puzzle. Referred pain. Yeah, hearing we’re talking about things like the sort of common Myofascial trigger point referred pain, but there’s also some important other aspects of preferred pain in the shoulder region from things like cervical nerve root pathologies that can refer pain down the upper extremity. And you you kind of mentioned some pain going down your upper extremity also, right? With this recent thing.
Til Luchau 27:19
Oh, that was my client. Well, that was your client. Yeah. Okay.
Whitney Lowe 27:22
Yeah. So again, I think it’s really important to try to make some distinctions about nerve-generated pain sensations down the upper extremity or into the shoulder region versus soft tissue things, because our treatment strategies are going to differ significantly for that. Because we, for example, don’t want to be pressing on things that are irritated nerves that one might be making things worse. We also might be in the wrong neighborhood because we’re doing all this stuff to somebody’s shoulder or arm, trying to make it stop hurting, and the problems up in their neck. So this is a a real critical thing to watch for, and and there are some important red flags here also, in terms of referred pain, that we as manual therapists a lot of times don’t think about too much. That I do think we should sort of call attention to, which is the visceral pain that gets referred to the shoulder region is well documented. For example, so heart and spleen that tend to refer to the left shoulder, and gallbladder and liver tend to refer to the right shoulder. Yes. So those those organ systems, and this is fascinating to me. I think in terms of like, why on earth does it do that? Me too. Yeah, but it has to do with the the what’s called the convergence projection theory, which is that the sensory nerves from many of from those structures are sort of synapsing at the same dorsal horn segments as those nerves from that particular shoulder region, and so the brain is getting confused about who’s yelling down there at the you know t4 level or whatever that particular level is, and it’s paying attention to the one that it thinks is more important, or that I hear a lot more from this one. So it must be this one here that I need to pay attention to, and so you get a lot of those sensations being referred there when it’s when it’s something else that’s that’s actually happening.
Til Luchau 29:16
And it’s worth it’s interesting too that organs, for the most part, haven’t evolved the capacity to locate sensation very well. They don’t map onto the brain in the same precise way that the rest of the musculoskeletal anatomy does. So it’s hard to hard for the brain to locate those. And so, like you say, dorsal horn confluence or something like that can be the way that the brain says, “Oh, it’s actually there, but it ends up not being physically there, but neurologically there.
Whitney Lowe 29:48
Yeah. Hey, I want to tap into that for a second. I don’t know the answer to this question. I’d love to hear your if you have an answer or want to speculate on this. Do you think that this is primarily because the amount of proprioception information that we. Have from myofascialal musculoskeletal tissues in terms of the reason that we have such a clearer somatosensory map compared to the organ systems.
Til Luchau 30:09
Why can we locate sensation in our musculoskeletal system so well and so poorly in our organs? Why is that? You’re asking.
Whitney Lowe 30:19
Yeah,
Til Luchau 30:19
yeah. I’ll bet it’s because again we we use our musculoskeletal system to to move and coordinate, and we want to sense joint position. We’re also touching the world with that, so we want to be able to locate the touch. There’s not a lot of tactile direct input to the organs, and so that may be not be needed. That might even be distracting. If I could tell you exactly where my breakfast was in my colon right now, that might be unnecessary information that I don’t need. Not only inappropriate to share in a podcast, but in the world in my functioning might not be necessary. So maybe the brain has found ways to prioritize functional sensation from one, so we don’t really need any attention.
Whitney Lowe 31:02
So we don’t have liver spinal cells or Golgi liver organs to give us that kind of specific information. Yeah, I think
Til Luchau 31:10
there’s probably some exceptions like the bladder. Bladder sensation is pretty highly sensitized. We get a lot of information about how our bladder stretches to it, yeah, and that’s one reason that urinary issues can be so disturbing and aggravating. Even medically, there it’s a fairly quote simple field. Often there’s there you know there’s not a lot of complexity compared to some other systems,
Whitney Lowe 31:37
yeah.
Til Luchau 31:38
But experientially, just urinary urgency, like the feeling of having to go, not being able to, is very disturbing. It’s really hard to have a good life when that’s going. Yeah,
Whitney Lowe 31:50
and I would imagine there’s some important evolutionary reasons for making that sensation be really prominent there. So all
Til Luchau 31:56
on a soil, the nest or whatever. Yeah. Yeah. Uh huh.
Whitney Lowe 31:59
Yeah. Yeah.
Til Luchau 32:00
So, okay. What anything else about referred pain, neurological contribution? Well, again,
Whitney Lowe 32:06
I think it’s back a lot to the history too. Like this is thing. These are things that should get picked up in the history. Like, what’s a quality? And this is back to that. I did that podcast episode a while back about the OPQRST framework and history taking, and this is a good example of that. Like, what what’s the quality or description of those sensations, and how are they getting reproduced? Is it from pressure on a particular point, or is it just you know vague sensations going down the upper extremity, or what kind of things that we can do to pinpoint whether or not this is a local shoulder tissue, or is this something that is being referred from some other location; those are really critical parts of the evaluation process. There,
Til Luchau 32:46
that’s a great episode and great application of it here. Just
Whitney Lowe 32:50
the
Til Luchau 32:50
history taking and the process of thinking through what’s our best or most likely route and how do we make those decisions as we go.
Whitney Lowe 32:58
Yeah, and just to reiterate the it’s so common for us to focus our attention primarily on nerve compression problems because that’s what we hear about so much but neural tension problems can do the same type of thing and through the shoulder particular I remember hearing an interesting story from a colleague who developed a I believe it was a an ulnar nerve. Can’t remember if it was an ulnar or median nerve injury. Anyway, she had reached forward to grab a hold of a door that she was going to push open, and someone was on the other side of the door and pulled the door open really fast, while her hand was kind of like stuck on the doorknob, and so like it jerked her arm with a sudden traction injury, and she had a pretty extensive neural presentation in the upper extremity for for weeks, just as a result of that one little kind of tug and pull that was just too much on her. Yeah.
Til Luchau 33:53
Well, the other classic one is a lateral whiplash.
Whitney Lowe 33:56
Yeah,
Til Luchau 33:57
now stretches the brachial plexus in the arms down the nerves, and
Whitney Lowe 34:00
yeah,
Til Luchau 34:01
contributes to this ongoing symptoms there.
Whitney Lowe 34:04
Yeah. So let’s talk a little bit about treatment here. We’ve been talking about how do we sort of figure out this. How does this influence treatment and the way the way we work?
Til Luchau 34:16
Yeah. Is it local or is it broader? Are we thinking regional? Are we thinking specific structures? I think a lot of that you’ve laid the groundwork for us by your emphasis on history taking. But there’s also again palpation. I might find things that are sensitive, and that’s that may or may not be my target of my pressure, but that’s going to be important for me to know too. Is it about calming these sensitive spots? Is it either with, say, a trigger point approach would tend to put some pressure into them and wait for them to subside, or there other approaches that might. Gently tease them apart from the periphery, give them a place to diffuse into, as opposed to zapping them. There’s also, you know, like dry needling or things like that that really go right for the most sensitive zones. So I think those are maybe stylistic differences. How do I do it? I think I pick a theory and give it a try, and then track the results. And I’m thinking across all these things we mentioned. Are there mechanical factors there? Are there sensory or neurosensitization issues there? And I’ll pick one of those again. I’m not going to do trigger point work if I think it’s about sensitization, particularly because I don’t need to add more sensitivity or more signal to that scenario. I need to calm it down more, and so in that case, it it may be starting broader other places in the body, gentle movement patterns, finding non threatening touch. Interesting along my pathway, which in some ways, like you said, is a pretty classic presentation of of an you know of an injured tissues progression over time. I’ve gotten a lot of really good work. I was in Thailand at the time at a body work retreat, and there were really exceptional body workers who tried to help me with this injury-they all felt great. I can’t say they made it improve measurably the next day. So it just, in my case, it just needed time. And then there was a stage, maybe three months or so into it, where I re-aggravated it by by some by inviting some more direct work. I thought, okay, now some time for some more sliding, gliding around that tendon. It’s actually a PT who diagnosed it pretty precisely as to exactly which structures were there, and she said, let’s do some, you know, specific manual therapy that ended up aggravating it again, unfortunately, and then this is where I’m going. It’s like I went to a friend who’s a very intuitive body worker who just did this almost like inner journey kind of body work with my shoulder, where she went in there and was feeling her, taking a tour of all these structures, and I told her my history very carefully. I said, let’s not kind of aggressively try to work it out, but I’m open to some exploration. So that’s exactly what she did. She was just touring, feeling, tracing the shapes in there. And I got to say, out of all the different things I’ve done, that’s the one session that made the most difference.
Whitney Lowe 37:39
Yeah,
Til Luchau 37:40
in terms of a noticeable improvement afterwards, that persisted.
Whitney Lowe 37:43
Yeah, it
Til Luchau 37:44
was just calmed and lubricated and felt great.
Whitney Lowe 37:48
Yeah, I want to just highlight something about that that I think was just an excellent example of how we make some of the treatment decisions that we make. And again, this is for me also illustrating how my thinking around these kind of pain problems has really changed and shifted over the years because this you know learning a whole lot more about pain science in particular and some of the different ways in which the body might you know respond this is a great example of how it’s not necessarily about a particular technique that was targeting a local tissue complaint at this at this point, it sounds to me like what got the most beneficial results was your body and you personally feeling a great sense of safety and interest in the palpatory exploration of this area. Without saying like I’m going to do this to this particular technique, it was more about how do you stimulate those affective touch tactile appearance. If you want to get you know technical neurological, like how do you stimulate that whole part of the nervous system to feel this is safe, effective touch that is going to be positively encouraging and let this area feel like okay we can turn down the alarm system on the pain here, and that’s so much like yeah what what really that’s to me seems like why that worked.
Til Luchau 39:15
That’s some of those timing. A couple months had passed. A lot of it was her, like she was like our last episode, we were talking about what’s the treatment, the technique, or the practitioner. It’s just her manner was she was the balm that soothed the womb in a way.
Whitney Lowe 39:33
Yeah,
Til Luchau 39:34
just her curiosity, her investigation, her gentleness, her exploration together. Yeah. So we again highlight absolutely positively do not underestimate the power of those things in making significant changes in in the people that you’re working with because those things have great power. I think personally that’s certainly my take and my bias. On it, yes, and it’s it’s I I really respect your ability to lay out pathways for people to assess what’s happening and come up with treatment plans, and then I’m also working so much in my own practice with monitoring in am I on track and how do I let the client or use the client’s input to help steer where we’re going. Yeah, like that improvisational conversation we had too. Like, what’s emerging now that I didn’t expect, or how is this dialog going, and how might I need to adapt from where I thought I was going?
Whitney Lowe 40:37
Yeah.
Til Luchau 40:38
So lots for me. I think there’s there is lots of movement during my shoulder work, active movement on the client’s part to investigate not just does it still hurt, which can itself be aggravating, but what is the pathway through here that feels the best, and oh that way still hurts, so let’s do something else. And meanwhile, with my hands, I’ll be investigating what happens between the layers, or around the tendons, or in the global structures that connect the arm to the torso and neck when someone’s doing these motions that feel good.
Whitney Lowe 41:15
Yeah,
Til Luchau 41:16
those kind of approaches there. Yeah, some of my treatment choices.
Whitney Lowe 41:20
Yeah. So, do you have? I mean, we kind of touched on this a little bit, but do you have instances where you would sort of say you’re deliberately going to avoid treating something that is particularly painful, like that particular painful tissue? Like,
Til Luchau 41:34
oh yeah.
Whitney Lowe 41:34
What are sort of those guidelines?
Til Luchau 41:36
The biggest shortcut, kind of a cheat, is I’ll ask the client, have you had body work or done things like that for this before? They say yes. It’s okay. Say did any of it make it worse? And so if they’re saying, oh yeah, I dig in with my cane myself, and but it’s staying aggravated, I might put that in that category. We don’t know if what they’re doing on themselves is keeping it aggravated, but for sure, if they say, “Oh yeah, I went to see that X practitioner and they did Y treatment, and boy, it really hurt after that, I’m going to go, “Okay, what can I learn from that so that we don’t duplicate that kind of approach? And then you know, of course, turning the question around: what has really helped, and what can we learn from that?
Whitney Lowe 42:22
Yeah, there’s an interesting, I think, sort of razor’s edge that we sometimes walk about painful treatments, and it’s I think really valuable to. Again, this is just sort of my perspective on this of where where we land on when is that appropriate because there are instances where treating a painful tissue and doing something that does increase some degree of discomfort has real therapeutic benefit. Absolutely,
Whitney Lowe 42:49
there is you know the classic example is a Myofascial trigger point that’s tender when you press on it. Well, you keep pressing on it, and it tends to deactivate the trigger point for a number of physiological reasons, one of which, however, is tied into the whole descending modulation neurological inhibition system, of you know you’re producing something that’s that’s producing a signal that’s causing the brain to say like, hey, let’s dump some endogenous opioids down in this area and turn down the volume on that particular area, but then there’s that place where you go too far and you press with too much pressure, and the body braces and splints up, and it becomes more aggravated. And now you’ve aggravated the system, and the the artistry. One of the pieces of great artistry in pain management treatment work, I think, is knowing where that blade, where that razor’s edge is, and knowing how to stay on the good side and not fall over onto the bad side of that.
Til Luchau 43:47
That’s true. That is the artistry, and the interesting factor is that the territory or the medium of our artistry changes over time as well. Like some of what I do today isn’t even going to take shape until tomorrow.
Whitney Lowe 44:03
Yeah,
Til Luchau 44:04
maybe it’s a little like tree surgeons in that sense. You know, it’s like we can’t just trim a tree to make it look good right now. We have to think about how it’s growing. Maybe we don’t just work on what presents itself as sort today. We have to think about how that’s going to evolve and progress over the coming time.
Whitney Lowe 44:21
Yeah, and I think that’s a great segue into looking at sort of this next piece. We’ve talked a lot about assessment and treatment strategies, but I think critically, an important part of this is restoring movement capacity and getting a person back to the activities that they want to be doing. You know, so how do we, how do we sort of blend in the the work that we’re doing? Because we’re not necessarily prescribing. Well, at least not. I won’t even say not even necessarily. We hopefully we are not prescribing exercise movements or things like that. But movement is important, and re integrating and reestablishing movement patterns is real. Important, and you gave an example a moment ago too when you were talking about your own shoulder, where it sounds like certain movement activities were probably started a little too early for where they needed to be, and that caused some potential aggravation of those problems to kind of flare up a little bit more here. And again, that’s that’s the kind of like where’s that Goldilocks zone of when is when is movement appropriate and what type of movement things will be really helpful to get started with? Yeah, yeah,
Til Luchau 45:31
and it’s I’ve again back to my story. I’ve had a couple different practitioners assess that and make suggestions, and in my case, I’m not say this works for everybody, but it it is the more it was has been the more free form, fluid, natural motions that I end up doing just as a part of other movements. Again, this is with my trainer, who’s pretty creative and just like doing like just get down to the floor and get back up. That’s one of my things. Now do that eight times in different ways.
Whitney Lowe 46:11
Okay.
Til Luchau 46:11
Now use your hands a lot. Now you don’t use your right shoulder. Now make do it only you know without your hands. So like all these variations of natural movements and slowing it down enough that I can feel okay that pathway is going to hurt. So let me find another pathway around that. I’d say that’s been some of the most helpful explorations and movement loading that I’ve done is the creative three dimensional investigation of which pathways are least painful. I also did a lot of band work prescribed by a very good PT, and the the the logic behind that is sound. You know, let’s do some loading of the tendon to calm it down, and there does seem there’s good evidence for that, and she was very specific in her exercises and her assessments. For whatever reason, that was less effective for me, even though I did stay with it and give it a try. Yeah,
Whitney Lowe 47:12
yeah. I think you know there’s two things that I think are really stick out for me in that description. There, one is noting that there, when we talk about loading tissues or movement things, we’re trying to do sort of two two different things. One is we’re trying to rebuild and condition tissues for the level of demand that is going to be placed on them, and that’s a sort of a mechanical loading mindset. And this is, of course, what’s predominant in physical therapy is like recondition the tissue for the demands that are going to be placed on it. Yes. The other part of that is dealing with the neurological integration of movement and training our brain to understand that this is a safe movement. And there was something in the statement you said just a second ago that was just like hit right on that when you said you were doing certain activities and you started to do something. You think like I’m not going to do that because that one’s going to hurt. You know, that’s kinesiophobia, which is something that anybody with a pain problem will go through. Which is that I think if I do this thing, this is going to hurt. And the more that gets reinforced, the stronger it gets, and the more we avoid those particular types of movements, so that has to be a gradual retraining, and that’s not about tissue loading as much as it is making the brain feel like this movement is safe and it’s okay. That is a real important part of that process too. I think.
Til Luchau 48:38
What’s the opposite of phobia? Philia. philia, kenosiophilia, like the love of philosophy, the love of knowledge, loving and movement, kinesiophilia. Yeah, I had to find my loved pathways as opposed to my phobic pathways.
Whitney Lowe 48:56
Oh, I like that. Yeah, I think we have we’ve just birthed a new movement modality here,
Til Luchau 49:04
kinesiophilia.
Whitney Lowe 49:06
That’s good. Oh yes. Okay, there we got some great marketing tricks in there too. Yeah, I see a wonderful logo coming along with that too. So, what else
Til Luchau 49:17
should we say about loading an activity? I love your distinction, by the way, between like conditioning, building it up, which can be great and useful. Yeah, that finding of kinesiophilic pathway as another option.
Whitney Lowe 49:32
Yeah, and so you know those those are two things that I think are really important. And as as manual therapist, I speak mostly to the massage therapy community, that’s what I’m most familiar with. There is this idea and distinction that you know we don’t do exercise things in terms of just telling clients you know how to exercise because that’s the realm of physical therapy. And certainly, from a professional practice standpoint, a lot of that is true. But there’s also a whole lot of aspects. Learning how to safely move and do things that are just basically instructional and educational suggestion things for people to explore how movement feels in their body. There’s lots of stuff that we can do. Lots of areas,
Til Luchau 50:13
just movement on the table. Someone lying on their side, exploring in space. Where does this feel good?
Whitney Lowe 50:18
Yeah,
Til Luchau 50:18
there’s a movement intervention.
Whitney Lowe 50:20
Yeah, but a great example of that is, for example, somebody who’s got like shoulder, let’s say like a shoulder impingement type of problem. It hurts when they abduct their shoulder because they’re doing it when they’re standing up and they’re loading certain muscles in a particular pattern. But what if they could lie on the ground and you know abduct their shoulder and let gravity just in the ground just hold up their arm, but get it into that position again. That’s retraining your brain that this motion with the arm held up is not necessarily damaging. It’s not necessarily dangerous. It’s okay, and so that reinforcing the safety of that movement is often a precursor to, and again, you want to do that stuff. In my opinion, you want to do that kind of work before you do the loading work that is designed to recondition those tissues. Because if they don’t feel safe moving in those directions, then the loading benefits are going to be outweighed by the flare up of the pain that’s going to be felt.
Til Luchau 51:21
Greg Layman’s calm shit down, build shit up. Exactly. Yeah. So
Whitney Lowe 51:25
that’s simple. Yep.
Til Luchau 51:27
Okay. So I’m just thinking of the armrest in my recent long flight.
Whitney Lowe 51:32
Yeah.
Til Luchau 51:33
The calming down is good. It’s not everything, because I I was at a limit of my capacity to adapt to this armrest. It just hurt to have my arm in that position, not have room to move it. My
Whitney Lowe 51:50
yeah,
Til Luchau 51:50
I was up against the wall on one side, and you know it was all full plane on the other side, and it was tough. So it’s it’s not like making it safe, which I have experienced a lot and can find ways to solves or fixes everything either. But that creates the conditions by which things could change. Then we get a situation like the airplane where I was challenged again and couldn’t find a safe or a comfortable position. I had to get creative and keep moving and find my way through it, and I arrived in the East Coast better than I would have if I hadn’t been creative. But still, I was pretty sore.
Whitney Lowe 52:31
Yeah, and I don’t also want to discount the, and I’m just going to make this up at the on the spot of the moment here, but the assumption that your just irritation with the inability to find a position of comfort also probably played into that process, you know, because that just happens for us. Like when we can’t get comfortable, you just get irritable, you know, because you can’t find that degree of comfort. And we do know that those things can also ramp up perceived pain sensations for for people.
Til Luchau 53:08
So maybe my irritation itself was part of that cyclic factor. If I could have found a peaceful, pleasant way to be crammed into that seat, maybe I would come out of the plane and place.
Whitney Lowe 53:20
But that’s a whole lot easier to say than it is to do, you know. So, just
Til Luchau 53:24
nice. When do we when do we change course?
Whitney Lowe 53:29
I think this always again. I’m gonna. I know I sound like a broken record, but I’m gonna keep coming back to the idea of assessment again. And this this is because I always like to emphasize that assessment is so much more than just what you do on that first intake. It’s the constant and continual evaluation of where you are, what you’re doing, how is the client responding, how is this particular approach that you’re using working or non-working. You know, those are the things that kind of tell us when do we kind of maybe need to change course and think about a different strategy or different approach. Does this fit in terms of what I think will likely be happening? You know, because one person’s shoulder pain can get really much better in a week or two treatments, and somebody else’s thing goes on for. I mean, you think about like an adhesive capsulitis problem, and this goes on for years, you know, with with long, with very very little change perceptible sometimes from from treatment to treatment.
Til Luchau 54:28
Yes. Well, again, looking for some cardinal rules here. If things get noticeably worse, yeah, I want to change course. Yeah. If the if the if there’s a flare up or worse thing that lasts for more than a day. Yeah, that can be hard though to tease out, especially if someone’s digging away on their shoulder with their own, you know, massage gun or whatever. It’s there’s you know I want to maybe that gets back to the history taking. What else are you? For self care, if they say, “Oh yeah, I got my massage gun, I got my foam roller, I got my cane, and then I have my daughter stand on it, I’m like, “Maybe I’ll say, okay, let’s maybe try an experiment where we take some of those out for a while and see how that does.
Whitney Lowe 55:17
Yeah, yeah, that’s a great guideline. I think of just that because there there are no absolute recipe books that are accurate for every person. There’s just so many individualized facets of this, and we need to explore you know what’s going to be ideal for each one of those which one each one of those people.
Til Luchau 55:35
And that if it’s not getting better, yeah, we need to change course. Yeah, it’s pretty clear because some of some of what we’re doing to try to help it could be keeping it in an aggravated state, and it’s hard to see that when it’s happening. Yeah, it’s hard to tell.
Whitney Lowe 55:49
Have you seen that like instances happen where somebody like you had an idea of something that was going on, and maybe your approach wasn’t particularly successful, but something else worked that you weren’t thinking would, or it went in a different direction.
Til Luchau 56:06
Sure, I had a client who, with shoulder pain, and we did a. He came to me for like an assessment session. We did an assessment. I did some work. It actually did reduce his neuropathic symptoms. He had less numbness, and then they came back later. I warned them they might. And for him, my approach would have been teaching him some self-care movements, some different things to think about in terms of movement and position. What ended up he latched onto and really helped with was some posture training. I didn’t expect that, so just how to hold his shoulders in the right, he said, right position, how to have correct posture, that really helped him, or he really found a way through that that I didn’t expect, and I wasn’t particularly Offering because I’ve seen that again be not helpful in so many cases, but in that case, yeah, it was something that I didn’t expect, and it was helpful for him.
Whitney Lowe 57:13
Yeah, those those are some of our best learning strategies, I think, too, when those things happen, of kind of like telling us, you know, where were we, where were we potentially off track, and and you know, needing to kind of make make a strategy change, or just listen to like this isn’t happening. Just maybe try something odd or different, or really, as long as it’s not violating a principle of, you know, something that’s inappropriate, but just see where something odd or different takes you. You know,
Til Luchau 57:49
try experiments. What happens if we stop everything for two weeks?
Whitney Lowe 57:55
Yeah,
Til Luchau 57:56
because and again, the paradox of like we can keep it aggravated is there is some perseverance that’s necessary in some cases too. You mentioned adhesive capsulitis not getting better sometimes right away. Yeah, it could be a process of a long time with some of these things. That again, we it we need to look at how what we’re doing, the value it provides to someone, how they perceive it out makes them feel, and then include the possibility that we could be keeping things aggravated and maybe try different approaches. Let’s just try some gentle holding, and then you know inside out guided expiration with breath this time, and yeah, does something else.
Whitney Lowe 58:36
Right. Yeah, I like that. I just like adding in little things that we might not have tried before, and see, like, does this make a difference? Does this change? Does this alter one way or the other?
Til Luchau 58:48
What are we getting to our home stretch here? Are we ready for our wrap up?
Whitney Lowe 58:52
Yeah, I think we’ve kind of covered a lot of you know key aspects of assessment concepts, treatment concepts, guidelines, things that would change. So, yeah. If we try to kind of look at where where we left, we I would say for me personally that you know starting with the basic pieces of information that I can gather most clearly. You know, thinking about the anatomy, what what structures are in there, what might possibly be causing it. Again, what are the the main things I can pull out of a client history that might tell me something about what’s going on there? Paying attention to what makes things worse, what makes them better, and does this fit into a particular pattern? And then looking at this in relationship to those pain phenotypes, and is this really at this early stage a nociceptive thing, or is this you know have neuropathic or nociceptive capacities to it; those kinds of things really guide that treatment process for me as well. That’s that’s really how I kind of tend to to look at this in a nutshell. So, how about you? Any any other things that we didn’t sort of get to? No,
Til Luchau 1:00:00
I think we’ve covered we’ve covered a lot, but I think just to try to encapsulate, I think it’s yeah we need to pay attention to what hurts, and then we need to also find ways to pay attention to what feels better. Yeah. So both in terms of movement explorations, but also our our touch and be able to track that. And it’s in like my example of my trainer texting me the next day, it’s a learning process that we have to adjust for a lot of shoulder pain in particular.
Whitney Lowe 1:00:26
Yeah,
Til Luchau 1:00:27
and and being in conversation with the client is the way to do that. And really presenting that to them too. It’s like let’s learn together. I want to know if it got worse. I want to know if it got better. We’re going to learn from that. Yeah, setting up that collaborative approach can be so helpful.
Whitney Lowe 1:00:42
Yeah. So we we started off at the. I was just going to say we start off at the very beginning talking about how common people bring these kinds of things to us. This is just sort of a a highlight for this stuff’s really pertinent to your practice. If you’re a manual therapist, you’re going to see a lot of things like this, so hopefully there’s some guidelines here and and things that can help you kind of get a sense of this. The
Til Luchau 1:01:07
shoulder is again a great laboratory for a lot of these concepts because it is so common because the role it has the you know the role of the neurology, the role of the structural pieces, the roles of the tissue, the roles of our function, what we do, all these things come together, yeah, and and they need to play into how we approach stubborn shoulders.
Whitney Lowe 1:01:28
Yeah,
Til Luchau 1:01:29
we got a closing question there. We proposed that what’s what’s one thing you wish you’d understood about shoulder pain earlier in your career? You got a thought on that, Whitney?
Whitney Lowe 1:01:38
Yeah, for sure. I would say that I think I spent a vast majority of my career in the world of thinking there was a lot stronger correlation between specific tissue pathologies and mechanical damage or irritation to them. So, really thinking about things through that orthopedic lens of tissue damage and tissue disruption driving most of these shoulder pain complaints, and and part of this will also have to do that. You know, with with some of the more much more recent science that’s come out of the sort of pain science exploration of of the whole role of the neurological system being much more significant, and the all the incredible proprioception from all these tissues that we’ve talked about being a big driver of what’s going on with the whole sensory experience there. So, I think for me, if there’s any one thing that I have learned and shifted significantly on, it’s it’s a move away from the more mechanical perspective of this region to a much more inclusive neurobiophysical, psychosocial kinds of exploration for what might be producing a lot of the sensations that people are feeling. How about you?
Til Luchau 1:02:59
Similar for me. It’s it’s that I learned some movement or mobility-inducing techniques that really seem to help a lot of clients, and that was the focus of my work with painful shoulders for many years. And I wish I’d learned earlier the role of sensitivity, the role of Just protective pain that, and how to calm things down. Movement calms things down, or it can. But I again, this session that I did with my friend, who was just this intuitive exploration of my anatomy and the sensations from the inside. I I would have liked to have had even more years practicing that.
Whitney Lowe 1:03:43
Yeah, yeah, wonderful.
Til Luchau 1:03:46
Today, the Thinking Practitioner Podcast is proudly supported by ABMP Associated Body Work and Massage Professionals, the premier association for dedicated massage and body work practitioners like you. When you join ABMP, you’re not just getting industry-leading liability insurance. You’re gaining practical resources designed to support your career, from free top tier continuing education and quick reference apps like Pocket Pathology and Five Minute Muscles. ABMP equips you with the tools you need to succeed and grow your practice.
Whitney Lowe 1:04:18
And ABMP is committed to elevating the profession with expert voices, fresh perspectives, and invaluable insights through continuing education courses, the ABMP podcast, and Massage and BodyWork Magazine, featuring industry leaders like my co-host Til and myself. Thinking practitioner listeners like you can get exclusive savings on ABMP membership at abnp.com forward slash thinking. So join the best and expect more from your professional association. And as always, we would like to say a thank you to all of you all for hanging out with us here today, and to our sponsors. As always, you can stop by our sites for the video show notes, transcripts, and any extras, and you can find that over on my site. At academyofclinicalmassage.com, Til. How about for you? Where can people find that?
Til Luchau 1:05:05
People can find all of the podcast stuff at advanced dash trainings.com. and we want to hear from you with your ideas about the show. What’s worked with shoulders? What hasn’t worked with shoulders? What did we leave out? What are you glad we said? You can email us at info@thethinkingpractitioner.com, or look for us on social media or YouTube, where you can comment, you can post, you can quibble, you can critique, you can celebrate, you can do all that social media stuff right there on our posts about the podcast. We’re under you can find us in social media under our names. My name is Til Luchau Whitney Lowe. What is your name?
Whitney Lowe 1:05:44
I think you said it pretty well that my name is Whitney Lowe. Today, where can people find me? That’s where they can find me. So, what we would really appreciate it if you would rate us, if you will, on Spotify or Apple Podcast. I know we say that all the time, but it really does make a difference in helping other people find the show. So, if you can, please take a few seconds to do that. And as always, thanks so much for spending some time with us here, letting us hang out in between your earbuds, and we will see you in the next time. Thanks again, Whitney. See you later. All right, thank you.

Live Workshop Schedule
Stay Up to Date
…with the Latest Episode, News & Updates
Get our free Techniques e-Letter
You’ll occasionally receive the latest schedule updates, tips, secrets, offers, resources, and more. Check out our ironclad privacy and SMS policies. You can unsubscribe/stop at any time.
This Month’s Free Online Course
Our gift to you. Includes CE, Certificate, and Extras.
Follow Us
Join us on FaceBook, Instagram, Twitter and YouTube for information, resources, videos, and upcoming courses!






0 Comments